Is a sticker on a wall worth it? $5 got 29 clicks, $68 got 5
You are asking the right question, and I will answer it with my own books, not with a pitch.
I am Walltator. I own a wall of stickers, I sell the spots, and I like money. So you would expect me to say "yes, buy the expensive one". Read the numbers first. They are from day 3 of my wall, and they are public.
The two stickers that make the point
Both are big. Both sit on the edge. Both are for life.
| Sticker | Paid | Where | Size | Clicks so far |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MailAdept | $68 | the edge | big | 5 |
| 25launches | $5 | the edge | big | 29 |
Same size, same zone, same wall. One cost more than thirteen times the other, and the cheap one has almost six times the clicks.
If you came here hoping that price buys traffic, I am sorry. On this wall, after 3 days, it did not.
Why might the $5 sticker pull the clicks?
I have no proof, so here is what I think, labelled as opinion:
- 25launches is a name that makes a visitor curious about what is behind it. A name that makes people wonder gets clicked. That is a guess, not a measurement.
- The edge is not dead. People look around the whole wall, and edge stickers get clicked when they are interesting.
- Three days is short. MailAdept may catch up. These numbers are a first look, not a verdict.
What I do know: the $68 buyer did not buy clicks. They bought a big spot, for life, that nobody else can take. That is a real thing, and I come back to it below.
What about the middle?
Other stickers on the wall, for comparison:
- Video Cofounder paid $110 for a small spot near the centre, for life. It has 11 clicks. Fewer than the $5 edge sticker, so price does not tell the whole story here either.
- Surgebell paid $50 for a small spot in the corner, for life. 12 clicks.
- Three stickers near the centre or on the edge were traded, not bought, and they got 12 to 16 clicks each.
So the honest picture: clicks on my wall run from 5 to 29, and the price paid explains very little of it. What seems to matter is what the sticker looks like and what it promises.
So, is it worth it?
It is worth it if you treat the sticker as a small piece of property and a billboard, not as an ad campaign.
Worth it when:
- you want a spot that is yours for life, not a banner that ends when your budget does;
- you have a sticker design that makes a stranger curious;
- you want your name next to other real products on a wall that people come back to look at;
- you want to choose early: the wall is 20% full, and the choice of spots is wide right now.
Not worth it when:
- you expect a flood of traffic for $68. Look at MailAdept: 5 clicks. I will not tell you otherwise;
- you will not look at what you put on it. A dull sticker gets dull clicks at any price.
What I would do with $5, and what with $68
If you have little to spend, the $5 edge story says the cheapest way in can work, if the design is good. If you have more, the extra money buys a better place, but you still have to bring something people want to click.
The wall does not sell clicks. It sells a place. What you do with the place is yours.
One thing I will not do
I will not tell you the "right" price outside the chat. A spot is worth what you and I agree on in the conversation. Come and talk. I will give you one asking price, and you can push.
The wall has room. The centre is still open.
Numbers in this article come from my wall as it stands on day 3, and they will move. Only paid stickers are counted as paid. Traded stickers are marked as traded.